[SCA-AS] [Fwd: TMR 08.02.15 Urban, Medieval Mercenaries (Williman)]

Mon Feb 18 12:34:13 CST 2008

Thought this book might be of interest to some subscribers on this list!

---------------------------- Original Message ----------------------------
Subject: TMR 08.02.15 Urban, Medieval Mercenaries (Williman)
From:    "The Medieval Review" <tmrl at indiana.edu>
Date:    Sun, February 17, 2008 2:41 pm
To:      tmr-l at indiana.edu
         bmr-l at brynmawr.edu
--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Urban, William. Medieval Mercenaries: The Business of War.
Foreword by Terry Jones. London: Greenhill Books; St. Paul: MBI
Publishing, 2006. Pp. 304. $39.95. ISBN-13: 978-185367-697-0; ISBN-
10: 1-85367-697-7.

    Reviewed by Daniel Williman
         Binghamton University
         danielw at binghamton.edu

This discursive and chatty book, co-published by two military-history
presses, contains fourteen chapters plus preface about war, not
limited either to the medieval or to mercenaries. There is a
laudatory Foreword by Terry Jones, author of Chaucer's Knight: A
Portrait of a Medieval Mercenary, but better known as a member of
the Monty Python collaborative. The Preface states three purposes of
the book: it "describes how mercenaries created the business of war";
it treats "the popular literature that has created our imagined world
of medieval mercenaries," because "what we believed happened is almost
as important as what actually did take place"; and thirdly it
investigates the importance of mercenaries. Urban cites Sellar and
Yeatman's 1066 and All That and Richard Armour's spoof
histories as witnesses for his principle that "historical truth is
what people remember."

Chapter 1, "Early Medieval Mercenaries," is devoted to England from
the Conquest to the Anarchy. Chapter 2, "Early Italian Mercenaries,"
goes to the thirteenth century. Chapter 3, "The 'Classic' Medieval
Mercenary," is an attempt at exploring and defining that concept.
Chapter 4, "Chivalry," begins with Froissart as a publicist of noble
military activity, moves to Shakespeare's Henry V
inconclusively, then has a section on "Younger Sons," "Free
Companies," the Ottoman Empire and the Visconti, blood, and Huizinga,
without any argument to link the subjects.

Chapter 5, "The Hundred Years War: Part One," goes to 1415. Chapter
6, "Forming the Victorian Imagination: Chaucer's Knight and Twain's
Saint," quotes the "General Prologue," lines 43-78, mentions John
Aubrey and praises Terry Jones at length, then goes on to Mark Twain's
Prince and the Pauper, Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's
Court, and Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc, again
without connecting to the title theme. Chapter 7, "Forming the
Victorian Imagination: The White Company," is devoted to that
adventure tale of Conan Doyle with brief mention of Sir Nigel.
Chapter 8, "The Crusades in the Baltic," uses material from Urban's
Baltic Crusade (1975, 1994), Prussian Crusade (1980),
Tannenberg and After (2004) and his translation of the Livonian
Chronicle with Jerry Smith (1997). Eisenstein's 1938 movie
Alexander Nevsky gets a section to itself.

Chapter 9, "The Hundred Years War: Part Two," runs from 1415 to 1491,
with emphasis on the battle of Agincourt according to Henry V,
but the section "War for Profit" returns to 1388 and Prussia without
explanation. Then there is some Henry IV, Part I, some of
Shaw's Saint Joan, and some French dynastic history. Chapter
10, "The Renaissance," is about Italy, starting with Froissart, a
section about John Hawkwood, then a jump to 1494 and Giovanni de'
Medici. Chapter 11, "The Black Guard," is about the early sixteenth-
century suppression of the commune of Dithmarschen, the subject of
Urban's 1991 book. Chapter 12, "Machiavelli," recalls that The
Prince was addressed to Giovanni de'Medici (cf. Ch. 10). Chapter
13, "Mercenaries in the Late Medieval Baltic," carries the story of
Ch. 8 from 1410 to 1502. Chapter 14, "Summary," says that war is
unending and mercenaries dangerous but inevitable, and calls on the
medieval fictions of Sharon Kay Penman and Ellis Peters to witness.

The titles of this book encourage certain expectations.  It should
include a general picture within a recognizable period, of mercenary
forces as distinct from other sorts of military formations, with some
treatment of the economic or managerial side of mercenary warfare.
Those expectations were not well fulfilled in the book.  The sketch of
chapters above shows the loose periodization.  There is no meaningful
biography, typical or singular, no picture of material, arms or
tactics in any period, no account of contracts or sharing out of pay
and plunder.  The war stories involve men in contracted military
companies, armed free brigands, and the infantry and horsemen of state
and even feudal arrays.  Citation notes are missing, and a short list
of Sources by chapters stands in for a bibliography.

The extended passages that Urban quotes from the adventure romances of
Conan Doyle and the satirical romances of Mark Twain provided a relief
for this reviewer and recalled the excitement of first readings at age
twelve.  Terry Jones, with his medieval peasant jokes in Monty Python
and his Holy Grail lampoon, has been a recurrent delight for years.
The weaknesses of this book as a historical study are not the fault of
those decorations.

Kenneth Fowler published his Medieval Mercenaries, Volume I:
The Great Companies, in 2001. He wrote there the history of
the routiers in France from the treaty of Bretigny in 1360,
which uprooted the garrisons of scores of towns and fortresses without
repatriating them, creating a new military, economic and social
reality in France that was revolutionary in its effects. The too-
long-delayed second volume was planned to follow those forces and
their customs, particularly with the Bretons and John Hawkwood, into
Italy. With his careful use of archival evidence, scrupulous
footnoting and bibliography, Fowler wrote the sort of book that Urban
dismisses (291) as "dry as dust history." But readers of The
Medieval Review will probably prefer it to something more fluid
and soupy.

-- 
-- Jenne Heise / Jadwiga Zajaczkowa
jenne at fiedlerfamily.net